yellow mustard, burn, science behind home remedies

Over the years, we have heard about scores upon scores of home remedies for everything from arthritis to warts. Some make sense intuitively, while others seem silly. Most have never been subjected to scientific scrutiny. Is there any science behind home remedies?

We may never know the full answer to that question, but occasionally we learn years later that there are scientific explanations. Several years ago, as we began to learn about transient receptor potential (TRP) channels in cells, a number of seemingly unrelated and otherwise inexplicable home remedies began to fall into place. Why does a spoonful of yellow mustard stop muscle cramps so quickly? How does pickle juice work for the same problem? Could a bar of soap under the bottom sheet really help prevent nighttime leg cramps?

What Is the Science Behind Home Remedies?

One of the appeals of home remedies is that you can do your own experiments at home. One mother wrote to us about testing the efficacy of putting Vicks VapoRub on the feet to calm a nighttime cough. Both her twins had bad colds, but she had only enough Vicks to treat one of them. The other twin coughed all night, while the treated twin slept soundly. The following night, having acquired more Vicks, she treated the other twin and left the originally-treated girl untreated for that night as part of a natural experimental control. Once again, the child who had been treated didn’t cough, and the untreated one did. It’s too small to be considered a scientific experiment, yet she proceeded scientifically in a spirit of inquiry.

N of 1 Experiments on the Science Behind Home Remedies:

It is always interesting to read about home remedies. What you really want to know, most likely, is “Will it work for me?” The only way to find out is to conduct an N of 1 experiment: try it. The N stands for the number of people in the trial–just you. You’ll get more information and your story will be more believable if you try to control as many factors as possible.

You may not end up with an explanation, but you’ll know whether or not the remedy is reliable for you. We have discussed a number of remedies that work for so many people that we feel we can count on them even though we still can’t explain them. Coconut (in cookies or on its own) seems to be good for stopping diarrhea. Soy sauce on a burn seems to ease the pain and reduce the redness. Do you have favorite home remedies that you rely on?

Here are a few studies you might find interesting on ginger, cinnamon and thyme.

What Are Your Questions About the Science Behind Home Remedies?

On this live show, we welcome your questions about home remedies. You can reach us by email at radio@peoplespharmacy.com, or call between 7 and 8 am EST on Saturday, November 10, 2018: 888-472-3366.

This Week’s Guests:

This week, we revisit briefly some interviews we have done previously with renowned experts.

Bruce Palmer Bean, PhD, is the Robert Winthrop Professor of Neurobiology at Harvard Medical School. He helped develop HotShot.

Tieraona Low Dog, MD, is an internationally recognized expert in the fields of integrative medicine, dietary supplements, herbal medicine and women’s health.  Her latest book is Fortify Your Life: Your Guide to Vitamins, Minerals and More. For more information, see her website: drlowdog.com

Listen to the Podcast:

The podcast of this program will be available the Monday after the broadcast date. The show can be streamed online from this site and podcasts can be downloaded for free. CDs may be purchased at any time after broadcast for $9.99.

Buy the CD

Download the mp3

Air Date:November 10, 2018

Get The Graedons' Favorite Home Remedies Health Guide for FREE

Join our daily email newsletter with breaking health news, prescription drug information, home remedies AND you'll get a copy of our brand new full-length health guide — for FREE!

  1. Heide K.
    Delray Beach, FL
    Reply

    Twice I used black pepper on a bleeding finger and both times it stopped the bleeding IMMEDIATELY. One was when I was on a cruise. My finger would not stop bleeding from chapped hands. My table mate reminded me that I told her about the black pepper. She applied it and the bleeding stopped. It does not burn as people around asked.

    I found that soy sauce applied to a burn prevented any pain or swelling.

  2. Terry
    Houston
    Reply

    When I was in the second grade I developed a terrible illness where I could not keep any food or liquids down. After about two weeks I was really weak and very skinny. The doctors could not figure out what was wrong. New neighbors moved in (with the grandmother with them) and she told my mother to put a mustard plaster on my abdomen. My mother smeared yellow mustard over a cotton dish cloth and folded it and put it on my abdomen. I immediately stopped throwing up and I could eat and drink after that and I got well!

    I have since used this several times when I was throwing up and it worked immediately. I even had a kitten that kept throwing up and I put a little mustard plaster on his little tummy and held him and he quit throwing up.

  3. fred
    Reply

    There is a certain arrogance that the scientific community (of which I have been one for 56 years) has about home remedies. If a remedy is not produced by Big Pharma with FDA approval, it is not worthy of application. Those remedies that are officially approved are those MDs will prescribe and/or recommend because it covers them against liability.

    To my scientific mind, time-tested home remedies that work again and again among a diversity of population are safer and more reliable than those produced by Big Pharma whose tests are often biased and flawed in their favor.

  4. tom
    ON
    Reply

    I have had a problem with severe inner thigh muscle leg cramps for years. I read an article by a veterinarian regarding the use of calcium in farm animals and, as a result, bought some OTC Calcium/Magnesium pills. If I take one of these pills every couple of weeks I get no cramping at all. I discovered this cure about 5 years ago, and it still works!

  5. Donna Curry
    Buffalo NY
    Reply

    I am enjoying your show on home remedies, I personally tried soy sauce for burns. I burned my hand while cooking and began to run it under cold water, it was then that I thought of using soy sauce. I knew it was recommended for burns. It worked beautifully, the burn pain died and there was no blistering. I highly recommend it, the burn also healed quickly. I have had many burns on my hands (klutzy cook) nothing has worked so well.

    • Lisa
      Bloomsburg, PA
      Reply

      I hear you, Donna. I am a klutzy cook as well. Soy sauce has saved me several times!

  6. Gloria
    Tampa, FL
    Reply

    I’ve used 1Tbsp of plain yellow mustard each of the last four times I woke up with horrible muscle cramps in my leg and/or foot. Each time, the cramps subsided in 3-4 minutes.
    I’m a grateful believer in this home remedy!

  7. jon
    N.R.H. Texas
    Reply

    Listening to Dr. Bean’s hypothesis this morning explains why when I can catch leg and foot cramps early enough I can concentrate on making the cramping muscles relax and the cramps stop. If the cramp is full blown, like when it awakens me, my little pea brain can’t dwell on anything except the number 9.5 pain. But then the mustard or pickle juice can usually stop that.

    Thanks so much for your show and its information.

    Jonsulli

  8. Dianne
    Tryon N C
    Reply

    I was taken off one of my beta blockers and put on 3 cups (36 ounces) of hibiscus tea and my blood pressure is lower than on the med.

  9. JJ in 80's
    Buckley, Wash
    Reply

    FYI. READERS Digest Oct 2018 & or Nov had big list of items that were addressing this issue that there are a lot of old doctor’s remedies that are now supported by scientific studies

  10. LIsa
    Bloomsburg, PA
    Reply

    I am a big fan of trying a home remedy. I had a constantly returning wart on my middle finger. Any OTC remedy I tried worked for a short time. Finally, I cut a banana peel to cover the wart and wound duct tape around it to prevent any air getting in. I left it on for two days. When I removed the tape, I could see the “threads” or veins of the wart. It was drying up. It fell off a day or two later and has never returned. That was almost 20 years ago.

  11. Kat
    Florida
    Reply

    All I know is that yellow mustard works great for burns. I recently badly burned the inside of my thumb while taking a hot pan out of the oven. I ran cold water over it first, then slathered it with mustard. As the mustard dried, I’d add more. Then I wrapped it with some gauze, and replaced it later in the day. The next day i had a large blister covering the entire area, but I wrapped it again with mustard/gauze. By the following day the blister was gone (the skin eventually came off) and I had no residual effects from the burn. My husband was amazed. The initial pain lasted only about 2 hours.

    • Phyllis O.
      TX
      Reply

      I, too, used duct tape for a plantar wart on my little toe and put a bandage around that. It had been frozen off twice before. It has not returned in 20 years. My doctor was very fascinated.

  12. Mary Jane
    NYC
    Reply

    Let the scientists satisfy themselves about these remedies. I don’t need their imprimatur in order to accept a solution that works.

  13. Rex Stroud
    Bedfprd, IN
    Reply

    Mustard does help with cramps.

  14. judie
    New York
    Reply

    If a home remedy works for me, I don’t need scientific proof to convince me. I’m satisfied if the results are positive for me.

What Do You Think?

We invite you to share your thoughts with others, but remember that our comment section is a public forum. Please do not use your full first and last name if you want to keep details of your medical history anonymous. A first name and last initial or a pseudonym is acceptable. Advice from other commenters on this website is not a substitute for medical attention. Do not stop any medicine without checking with the prescriber. Stopping medication suddenly could result in serious harm. We expect comments to be civil in tone and language. By commenting, you agree to abide by our commenting policy and website terms & conditions. Comments that do not follow these policies will not be posted. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your cart

Total
USD
Shipping and discount codes are added at checkout.