Most animals make strong stomach acid (hydrochloric acid or HCl). Sharks make stomach acid. So do snakes, camels, cows and hamsters. Of course, humans also make stomach acid. Was it all a big mistake? Did Mother Nature mess up? Many scientists believe that stomach acid is crucial for maintaining a healthy microbial community (microbiome) in the human gut (PLOS One, online, July 29, 2015). Could acid-suppressing drugs cause allergies and other unanticipated mischief?
PPIs and the Law of Unintended Consequences:
Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) such as esomeprazole (Nexium), lansoprazole (Prevacid) or omeprazole (Prilosec) are popular acid-suppressing drugs. Doctors prescribe them for a wide range of intestinal disorders and people take OTC versions for nearly any kind of digestive complaint.
A few decades ago doctors were fond of saying “no acid, no ulcer.” Every medical student, resident and gastric surgeon believed that if they could just control stomach acid, they could cure peptic ulcers. If antacids didn’t work, then surgical intervention to reduce acid might be seriously considered (Journal of the American College of Surgeons, January, 2010).
The PPIs Dominate:
Antacids like aluminum hydroxide, calcium carbonate, magnesium hydroxide and sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) used to be very popular. Then along came H2 antagonists (histamine blockers). Drugs like cimetidine (Tagamet), famotidine (Pepcid) and ranitidine (Zantac) were high on the doctors’ hit parade of popular medications. Such drugs were hugely successful for years.
When proton pump inhibitors came along, though, they quickly displaced the H2 antagonists. PPIs were much more powerful at suppressing stomach acid. Doctors loved this category of drugs because they could cure stomach ulcers fast. PPIs were also quite effective at easing symptoms of indigestion. Drugs like Prilosec and Nexium became blockbusters.
How Safe Are PPIs?
The prevailing view for decades has been that acid-suppressing drugs are quite safe. This view has been tempered by the recognition that long-term use is linked to a greater risk of bone fractures, kidney problems and infections. Read more about PPI complications as this link:
You may also want to review this article:
Can Acid-Suppressing Drugs Cause Allergies?
Scientists in Austria have found that people taking PPIs are almost twice as likely as other patients to need allergy medicine for hives (Nature Communications, July 30, 2019). They reached this conclusion by analyzing medical records of eight million adults, covering 39 million person-years of follow-up. This represented 97% of the Austrian population between 2009 and 2013.
The authors introduce their concerns this way:
“The view on PPI as harmless co-medication has increasingly been challenged by reports of potentially related complications, e.g., increased risk of osteoporotic fractures, Clostridium difficile or other enteric infections, pneumonia, and many more, especially in long-term usage. Over the past years, our group developed the concept that gastric acid inhibitors also promote the development of allergic disease not only in adults, but even imprinting the next generation for allergy.”
The kind of epidemiological research linking PPIs to allergies cannot prove cause and effect. It is an association, albeit a strong one. One reason we tend to believe that acid-suppressing drugs cause allergies is the dose response curve. The greater the long-term use of PPIs, the more likely people were to receive anti-allergic medications.
Why Would Acid-Suppressing Drugs Cause Allergies?
There are various theories to explain the data. For one thing, less acid in the stomach means altered digestion. Proteins are not broken down as effectively when acid levels are reduced. The presence of these proteins may increase the risk of allergic reactions.
PPIs also affect the microbiome. When acid is suppressed, the microbial population of the gut changes. This may lead to an altered immune reaction in the body.
Gastroenterologists Resist Reports of PPI Side Effects:
When doctors prescribe a class of medications as frequently as PPIs, they tend to become a bit defensive if there are concerns about safety. We have seen articles in the medical literature disputing reports of PPI-related adverse reactions. Here is an analysis of a recent one that you may find interesting:
Please share your experience with PPIs in the comment section. Do you think acid-suppressing drugs cause allergies? If so, tell us why.