doctor boxing

Statin-type cholesterol-lowering drugs have been controversial for decades. Atorvastatin (Lipitor), lovastatin (Mevacor), rosuvastatin (Crestor), simvastatin (Zocor) and similar meds have made tens of billions of dollars for their manufacturers. How good are such drugs at saving lives? Is stopping statins a “threat to public health?”

The Polarization of Medicine:

Many Americans are distressed about the current level of polarization in politics. What they might not realize is that certain topics in medicine have also become quite polarized.

The Statin Enthusiasts:

One such is statin treatment for elevated cholesterol levels. Many cardiologists are adamant that statins are crucial for protecting people from heart attacks and strokes.

Some have stated, almost seriously, that statins are so beneficial that they should be put in the water supply. They maintain that side effects are relatively rare and usually mild for most patients. Stopping statins, even if someone is experiencing muscle pain or weakness, is considered counterproductive to heart health.

Recommendations from the American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology would require that 97 percent of Americans between 66 and 75 be taking statins (JAMA Internal Medicine, Jan. 2015).

The Statin Skeptics:

Other cardiologists, however, point out that statin benefits are modest. Dr. Robert Dubroff and Dr. Michel de Lorgeril writing in the World Journal of Cardiology (July 26, 2015) note that a number of key statin studies have failed to demonstrate a mortality benefit from such drugs.

An analysis of all randomized controlled trials involving a statin vs. placebo (BMJ Open, Sept. 24, 2015) concluded:

“The survival gains we found are surprisingly small. The highest value was 27 days, found in the 4S study, achieved by 5.8 years of simvastatin therapy in participants with a history of unstable angina or myocardial infarction [heart attack].”

The authors also noted that after years of statin treatment:

“The median postponement of death for primary and secondary prevention trials were 3.2 and 4.1 days, respectively.”

Cardiologists Dubroff and de Lorgeril pointed out in their article that statin side effects may be more common and more serious than clinical trials indicate. Some observational studies report adverse reaction rates of 20 percent, which leads to stopping statins (Annals of Internal Medicine, July 25, 2017).

Statin Skirmish Turns into Open Warfare:

The latest salvo in the statin wars appears in the pages of the Annals of Internal Medicine (July 25, 2017). A retrospective study evaluated the health of 28,255 patients seen at Brigham and Women’s Hospital or Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

All of these individuals had an adverse reaction to a statin cholesterol-lowering drug documented in their electronic medical record. Some of these people stopped taking the medication, although the majority continued on a statin.

Four years later, the researchers determined that 12.2 percent of those on a statin had experienced a heart attack, stroke or death from any cause. In comparison, 13.9 percent of those who had discontinued their statin met such a fate. The difference between the two groups is 1.7 percent.

Some cardiologists see this as a huge benefit. Others maintain that it is modest at best. The authors of this study state: “Continued use of statins after an adverse reaction may not be the optimal choice for everyone.”

Dr. Steve Nissen Goes After Statin Skeptics:

An editorial in the same issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine declares:

“Statin Denial:

An Internet-Driven Cult with Deadly Consequences”

Editorialist Dr. Steve Nissen of the Cleveland Clinic notes:

“Statins have developed a bad reputation with the public, a phenomenon driven largely by proliferation on the Internet of bizarre and unscientific but seemingly persuasive criticism of these drugs.”

He points out that:

“discontinuing statin treatment may be a life-threatening mistake.”

Dr. Nissen is very unhappy that more people are not taking statins. He argues that:

“56 million Americans are considered eligible for statin therapy, with about half actually receiving treatment.”

Dr. Nissen bemoans the fact that:

“We are losing the battle for the hearts and minds of our patients to Web sites developed by people with little or no scientific expertise, who often pedal ‘natural’ or ‘drug-free’ remedies for elevated cholesterol levels.”

It is Dr. Nissen’s opinion that if patients are stopping statins, a staggering number will die. He states that “statin discontinuation or non adherence has grave consequences.” He specifically targets what he calls “fad diets” that “offer patients the promise of nearly miraculous reversal of heart disease by dietary means.”

“In many cases, the advocates aggressively promote their dietary approach as an alternative to statins, promising all of the benefits with none of the risks.”

Dr. Nissen calls upon “thoughtful physicians” to counter these dangerous cults by explaining to our patients that:

“discontinuing statin treatment may be a life-threatening mistake.”

Who Are The “Cultists”?

Dr. Oz comes in for specific criticism in Dr. Nissen’s editorial. Although not specifically named, three prominent cardiologists may also be in Dr. Nissen’s crosshairs:

Rita Redberg, MD, MSc, is Professor of Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, and Director of the UCSF Women’s Cardiovascular Center. She is editor of one of the world’s pre-eminent medical journals, JAMA Internal Medicine.

Pascal Meier, MD, is an interventional cardiologist at University Hospital Geneva and The Heart Hospital, University College London Hospitals. He is Editor-In-Chief of Open Heart (BMJ), associate editor of the BMJ (British Medical Journal) and associate editor of the Cochrane Heart Group.

Aseem Malhotra, MD, is consultant cardiologist at London’s Lister hospital and at the Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust.

These highly regarded cardiologists wrote an editorial in the British Journal of Sports Medicine (April 25, 2017).

The title of their article:

“Saturated fat does not clog the arteries:

coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition, the risk of which can be effectively reduced from healthy lifestyle interventions”

The editorial in the British Journal of Sports Medicine emphasized that a Mediterranean diet reduced heart attacks and deaths dramatically even though it did not lower LDL cholesterol. The cardiologists concluded:

“It is the alpha linoleic acid, polyphenols and omega-3 fatty acids present in nuts, extra virgin olive oil, vegetables and oily fish that rapidly attenuate inflammation and coronary thrombosis.”

They go on to pin the tail on insulin resistance. These cardiologists suggest that chronically elevated insulin levels are “at the root of heart disease, type 2 diabetes and obesity.” Instead of worrying about LDL cholesterol, they say we should be “replacing refined carbohydrates with healthy high fat foods.”

Exercise is also central to their program. They point out that “30 min of moderate activity a day more than three times/week” lowers insulin resistance.

We do not believe that Dr. Nissen is really calling these cardiologists cultists. He has stated directly to us on the radio that a healthy lifestyle is essential for heart health and he has himself recommended a Mediterranean-type diet.

The Statin Skirmish Has Turned Ugly:

Like many Americans we are saddened that there is such polarization in politics. To see this kind of divisiveness spill over into medicine is even more disheartening.

The statin enthusiasts insist that stopping statins will lead to a large number of deaths. They downplay side effects.

The statin skeptics maintain that statins barely make a dent in mortality statistics. They point out that statin side effects such as muscle pain and weakness may limit exercise, which is essential for heart health and overall well being. They also note that statins may increase blood sugar and can lead to diabetes, which in itself contributes to heart disease.

It is no wonder that patients are confused. When highly credentialed cardiologists cannot agree about statins or diet it leaves the rest of us in the lurch.

Decide For Yourself:

If you would like to listen to Dr. Steve Nissen and Dr. Rita Redberg discuss these very issues on The People’s Pharmacy syndicated radio show, here is a link to a one-hour interview we conducted with both of these prominent cardiologists. Click on the green arrow inside the black circle above the plastic heart for free streaming audio. Make up your own mind based on the evidence they present.

Express your own opinion below in the comment section. Please be respectful of different opinions.

Get The Graedons' Favorite Home Remedies Health Guide for FREE

Join our daily email newsletter with breaking health news, prescription drug information, home remedies AND you'll get a copy of our brand new full-length health guide — for FREE!

  1. Frank

    I have been taking statin drugs for many years. I have constant muscle pain and weakness and memory loss with confusion. I am 78 yrs old and need off this drug. How can I stop this Med?

  2. Cheryl

    This is the fourth article I’ve read, this morning, regarding the statins controversy. The second one I read went into great detail about the first study cited in this article. That 1.7 % was the difference in mortality. Well, 1.7 was the exact number that I came up with when I did the math.

    However, the same article claimed that it was a 12% difference, and 1.7 was nowhere in the study summary.

    The next article I read called it a 13% difference (citing same study) and the next article claimed it was a 25% difference in mortality!

    What is going on?!!!

  3. Sue M.

    After being off Atorvastatin for several months because I was having cognitive issues, I had my cholesterol levels taken and I see my doctor next week. My numbers are not good and I know my doctor will want me to try a different statin even though I feel better and the cognitive issues have resolved. My history without a statin has been high cholesterol and changes in diet, etc. have not helped. I am struggling with what to do. Is there a statin that causes less cognitive problems than the others?

    Thank you,
    Sue M.

  4. Mike

    5 years ago I had a heart attack and an 8 way bypass. That failed and 4 of my bypasses plugged. The doctors told me I was probably going to die. Because they had nothing to loose, they decided to put 2 stents in my original arteries and I felt life come back into my body. They also put a defibrillator and home I went with my bag of meds. Sotolol, Statins 80 mg. and now I’m prediabetic with Metformin 1,000 mg. per day. I do not like taking these meds. but really didn’t notice too many side effects (maybe tired, low energy, depression, memory loss, I was a cranky old man) I’m not myself. I should be kicking up my heals with this second chance on life. I lost 60 lbs. my wife has me on a healthy diet. My doctors told me I would have no choice but to take these meds for the remainder of my life. Well, with my wife’s help, I gradually got off the Sotolol. My cardiologist was horrified…that’s impossible! No problems yet …. then I weaned myself off Metformin and I take a natural supplement “Sensolin” which is working unbelieveable. My A1C (6.0) is way better than with the Metformin. My diabetic doctor got really angry and said you have no choice but to take your Metformin. I stopped going to her. Then I cut my statin to 20 mg. slowly and substituted it with Omega 7 and a few other natural supplements. I take other healthy mutivitamins. My plan is to stop the statin all together. The statin raised my BS by almost 20 points. My heart function is back to normal and I feel better. Trouble is….my doctors don’t have any knowledge on healthy diet or natural supplements and they don’t want to hear about what I am doing and they would not approve. I haven’t had the courage to tell them.

  5. Rochelle

    I was put on simvastatin after heart attack and CABG in 2009. I had stents in 2014. I have been off and on statins. After reading “The Great Cholesterol Myth” I understand that it’s not cholesterol that harms your heart. It’s sugar, inflammation,oxidation and stress.

    I usually take the statins for about a month each year just before I have blood work so the doctors don’t know I’m not taking it. My last test 2 weeks ago showed total – 155, HDL – 74, Trig – 61, Non HDL – 81, LDL – 69.

    Pretty good, but when I went to see my new cardiologist he wants to put me on Lipitor, which I can’t tolerate. Then he wanted to change the simvastatin from 20 to 40 mg. I said I’ll think about it just to get him off my back. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.

    So yes, the doctors do everything they can to push statins. My husband has always been athletic and fit and was eating low-carb. When he got his blood work his cholesterol was up. Now he’s being put on 40 mg Lipitor and eating low-fat, more bread,jelly, honey. I’m worried but he is a compliant patient and trust the doctors.

  6. Carmen
    Oklahoma City

    My doctor put me on 5 different statins to lower my cholesterol. I had severe side effects from every one of them even after he lowered the dose several times. I was almost in a wheelchair when I finally stopped taking them on my own. He paid no attention to my complaints and told me to “work through the pain”. He was so insistent that I continue on a statin that I finally had to find another doctor. I am now on Repatha and my cholesterol numbers are great but I have noticed a big decline in my brain function. What next?

  7. Lil

    I have a question rather than a comment. I was prescribed 20mg Pravastatin after I had vascular surgery to patch an angioplasty go wrong on my left leg. The artery was scratched in the process causing leakage thus the vascular surgery to repair it.

    I do have high cholesterol but I was told it was not that high—-Just wondering if its worth all the cramping pain I get on my toes and fingers. Doctor said to get on Fish oil but I can’t take large capsules or pills and I have trouble finding small capsules. Still searching!

    • Mary

      Fish oil can be found in liquid form. Try health food store, vitamin shops and Amazon.

  8. Jan
    North Carolina

    I experienced being told I was diabetic after taking statins and I experienced sugar fluctuations that were very uncomfortable. I stopped taking the statins and felt better. I again let a doctor talk me into taking them again and I experienced the same sugar problem. The same doctor decided I was borderline diabetic. I was given Metformin and the statin and I slept most of the time. Whereas I was given Metformin, I wasn’t given a meter. Anyway, I got disgusted and stop taking the Metformin and felt better. Then I stopped taking the statin. For several years I had to listen to doctors saying I am diabetic and they seem to suggest I was just denying that I was. Now my A1C is below 6 with out either medicine and I feel better. But still doctors want to give the statins to me and I keep refusing. It seems they would rather have a diabetic with high cholesterol on medicine than one who has fair sugar levels who feels better.

  9. Fay Calhounit

    I refuse to take a station. So my doctor is ok with my taking fish oil supplements, virgin olive oil, avocados, and
    moderate exercise

  10. Fay Calhoun

    It’s my personal experience that statins are very harsh. The fat loss as a result of taking them causes memory loss.

  11. Kat

    When I was prescribed a statin I actually read the very small print in the brochure that accompanied the drug. It said that it would lower my cholestrol along with proper diet and exercise. I decided to just opt for the proper diet and exercise and lowered my cholestrol without any medication!

  12. Michael

    In Febuary of this year I had a heart attack and they put one stint and was prescribed a statin even though I did not really have high cholesterol numbers. After a month I started to notice my cognitive skills were getting worse. I mentioned it to my cardiologist and he lowered the dosage , after a month of taking this dosage things were getting worse mentally so I stopped taking the statin . After several weeks I started to feel better and now two months later I feel like my good ole self. I was fortunate that the heart attack did not kill me but I thought the side effects of the some of the drugs were going to do me in faster. No statins, eating clean and exercise, I feel has made a life better.

What Do You Think?

We invite you to share your thoughts with others, but remember that our comment section is a public forum. Please do not use your full first and last name if you want to keep details of your medical history anonymous. A first name and last initial or a pseudonym is acceptable. Advice from other commenters on this website is not a substitute for medical attention. Do not stop any medicine without checking with the prescriber. Stopping medication suddenly could result in serious harm. We expect comments to be civil in tone and language. By commenting, you agree to abide by our commenting policy and website terms & conditions. Comments that do not follow these policies will not be posted. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your cart

Shipping and discount codes are added at checkout.