prevent skin cancer, mother applying sunscreen to a young girl, oxybenzone

In the last few years, alert consumers have sought sunscreens that do not contain endocrine disruptors. Sometimes, this can be quite a challenge. Two consumer organizations have recently issued their recommendations for 2018, but their lists are very different. One took this concern into account and the other did not. Some readers have have asked about sunscreen without oxybenzone.

Looking for Sunscreen with No Hormone Disruptors:

Q. In the Consumer Reports ratings on sunscreen, most of the top ranked lotions contain oxybenzone (a.k.a. benzophenone-3 or BP-3). You have warned previously about the possible hormone-disrupting or endocrine-disrupting effects of this chemical in many articles. What are we to do?

A. You are right that many of Consumer Reports’ (CR) top rated sunscreens contain oxybenzone. Nevertheless, the organization acknowledges that the chemical contributes to coral bleaching. CR also notes that Hawaii has banned sunscreens containing ozybenzone starting in 2021.

EWG Rating Sunscreens:

The Environmental Working Group (EWG) is a nonprofit organization promoting human health with attention to environmental effects.

It warns that oxybenzone

“is a toxic chemical that is harmful to our health and our planet. It’s linked to hormone disruption and allergic skin reactions in people, as well as the bleaching of coral reefs and coral death.”

That’s why the organization is campaigning to have oxybenzone removed from sunscreens. EWG found it in a majority of the products they reviewed this year, but they also found more than 200 products that do not contain BP-3. You can check the list at EWG.org.

Common Sense for Sun Exposure:

Don’t forget that common sense can go a long way to preventing a burn. Try to schedule outdoor activities early or late rather than between 10 am and 2 pm when the sun may be most intense. A hat and sunglasses are essential gear, along with long sleeves when they are practical. Don’t be lulled into complacency by an overcast sky. You can burn even when the sun is not casting a shadow.

Get The Graedons' Favorite Home Remedies Health Guide for FREE

Join our daily email newsletter with breaking health news, prescription drug information, home remedies AND you'll get a copy of our brand new full-length health guide — for FREE!

  1. Marilee
    Florida
    Reply

    I would add a reminder to this story and the comments. Because there are two quite different sunscreen lists, EWG and Consumer Reports, one can take the best from each. CR focused on blocking harmful UVA and UVB sun rays to prevent burns, while EWG focused on safe ingredients. What I took from CR was that far too many sunscreens do not perform as advertised.

    Some which claim to be high SPF were in fact barely effective at all. Therefore, any near the bottom of CR’s ratings, no matter the ingredient list, I eliminated from my consideration. Then I examined the EWG list and compared it to the CR list. I was able to find some reasonably effective sunscreens that passed muster on both lists and did not contain oxybenzone.

    This personal research task took me considerable time and effort going through them all, cross referencing ingredients, etc. It should not be this hard! Both organizations have our best interests at heart, but approach their ratings from different angles, so confusion is inevitable.

  2. ariel
    USA
    Reply

    I found that some sunscreen for Babies does not have the harmful ingredient in it.

  3. Hank
    Left coast
    Reply

    Can you please give a short list of only the products that do not contain the problematic organic chemicals?

    Consumer Reports has a really miserable search tool on their review that doesn’t make it easy to narrow down from their long list.

  4. Marilee
    Florida
    Reply

    It is very confusing to see two respected organizations have two very different lists of approved and effective sunscreens. Personally, since I live in Florida and care about the potential damages done to corals and other aquatic life, not to mention my own health, I chose to not buy or use products that contain oxybenzone.

    Fortunately, some decently effective sunscreens, including some Consumer Reports find effective, are free of the chemical. I have been a subscriber to CR for over 30 years and usually respect their test standards. But in the case of sunscreens, feel let down by their lists and have written to them about it.

  5. Beverly C
    Villa Rica, GA
    Reply

    There are non toxic brands like Pure Haven that offer good protection without the chemicals.

  6. J. David A
    Springfield, MO
    Reply

    Sunscreen. Oxybenzone has not shown prevention of skin cancer (well a few kind of low grade cancers) – this is old drug. Para-amino-benzoic acid(PABA) did prevent cancer but had allergies and was taken off the market as a big mistake – 90%, not allergic and not able to prevent cancer. Chalk up one for cancer.

  7. Sherri
    Georgia
    Reply

    Don’t forget there are plenty of natural, non-chemical sunscreens on the market now at most stores. I use Goddess Garden. That one is even water resistant up to 40 minutes.

  8. Kim
    Reply

    A note should be added that EWG has found that sunscreens containing Vitamin A (retinyl) cause skin cancers as well.

  9. Art
    NM
    Reply

    The skin is the largest organ in the body and an excellent absorber of toxins into our systems. If you can’t eat something then you probably shouldn’t be putting it on your body. Virgin Coconut oil offers some SPF protection and is a great skin moisturizer and completely safe to use.

  10. Paul
    Goochland, VA
    Reply

    Sun exposure and sunscreen use is one of the areas with the worst science ever, backing various opinions. Anecdotally, growing up in the 60’s, skin cancer was not mentioned a lot, and no one wore sunscreen, and no one told you to limit sun exposure. Both my grandmothers, who lived to their late 80’s, grew up on farms and worked in the fields. One even retired to Florida. Neither had skin cancer or skin issues. Now we have turned into a society that works mostly indoors; kids don’t play outside; and for some reason skin cancer rates seem to be rising, despite all the warnings. I once joked that skin cancer rates seem to be rising at the same rate of sunscreen use.

    There may be some truth to it, after all. Your skin is an organ and absorbs most of what you put on it. I work outside, but will never use sunscreen. If I followed recommendations, I would be slathering dubious chemicals over my skin 300 days a year, twice a day. That would be ridiculous. Also, consider the many health benefits of adequate vitamin D. At 60 years old, I am still a believer in “moderation in all things.”

  11. Marian
    nyc
    Reply

    10-2 as hours of highest sun is odd given that most of the country observes Summer, which moves solar noon to 1pm. Shouldn’t this be adjusted according — call it 10-3??

  12. Kit
    Delaware
    Reply

    I too am using red yeast rice but was told to take COQ10 with it. Correct? Thanks for your newsletter.

    • Patricia
      Seattle
      Reply

      The environment has degraded considerably since the 1960s, with the thinning of the ozone layer. Not using sunscreen is deliberately deliberately putting oneself at risk, more so, depending on certain hereditary factors. That’s a choice anyone can make. But advocating it for others? No.

What Do You Think?

We invite you to share your thoughts with others, but remember that our comment section is a public forum. Please do not use your full first and last name if you want to keep details of your medical history anonymous. A first name and last initial or a pseudonym is acceptable. Advice from other commenters on this website is not a substitute for medical attention. Do not stop any medicine without checking with the prescriber. Stopping medication suddenly could result in serious harm. We expect comments to be civil in tone and language. By commenting, you agree to abide by our commenting policy and website terms & conditions. Comments that do not follow these policies will not be posted. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your cart

Total
USD
Shipping and discount codes are added at checkout.