close up of a doctor writing in on a chart

Several years ago we learned that British health professionals were told that they could no longer wear ties or white coats. In 2008 the UK’s National Health Service (NHS) banned ties and white coasts for doctors and nurses. The rule was that healthcare staffers needed to be “bare below the elbow.”

The point of the exercise was to try and reduce the risk that patients would be exposed to bad bugs: bacteria, fungi, viruses, etc. If the arms were bare below the elbow it would be easier to wash them thoroughly. The NHS was hoping to reduce the spread of MRSA and Clostridium difficile (C. diff) infections among others.

Sources of Infection:

Doctors have a name for things that transmit infection. They are called FOMITES. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines fomite as:

“an object (as a dish or an article of clothing) that may be contaminated with infectious organisms and serve in their transmission.”

Long sleeves, white coats, ties, stethoscopes, computer keyboards, doorknobs and jewelry can all harbor nasty stuff. And keep in mind that hospital acquired infections are a huge problem. The CDC has estimated that 100,000 people die in hospitals each year as a result of infections they caught in these institutions.

Resistance By U.S. Doctors:

I used to serve on a Patient Safety and Clinical Quality committee at one of the nation’s most prestigious hospitals. When the NHS announced the banning of white coats, ties and jewelry in the U.K. I asked the experts at this hospital about its plans to follow suit. I wasn’t exactly laughed at, but it was clear that the culture of medicine in America would not give up white coats easily. The infectious disease experts at this institution made it clear that there were no data indicating that white coats posed a problem. Without data they were not about to institute changes.

I was also puzzled to discover that there was no policy on cleaning white coats or ties. Interns, resident and attending physicians determined how often they would clean such articles of clothing on their own schedule.

Dr. Peter Pronovost Challenges His Colleagues:

Peter Pronovost, MD, PhD, is one of the world’s foremost patient safety experts. He is senior vice president for patient safety and quality at Johns Hopkins Medicine. On December 19, 2015 he wrote an article titled, “Why White Coats Should Be Optional.” It should be required reading for patients, physicians, nurses and any health care worker who comes into direct contact with patients.

Here are just a few key points:

“Would my white lab coat be better put to use when I carve the Christmas roast than when seeing patients?

“After all, we know that these coats can be covered with pathogens, including drug-resistant ones, which may be transmitted to patients. They are cleaned infrequently: In a survey of physicians, nearly 58 percent said they laundered their white coats monthly or never. Less than 3 percent washed them daily or every other day. What is the harm in adopting a ‘bare below the elbows’ policy for health care professionals — as has been done in the United Kingdom — to reduce the chance of transmission?”

Dr. Pronovost points out that doctors often resist new ideas unless they can be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt. That is probably why the infectious disease experts completely rejected my suggestion several years ago that going bare below the elbow might be beneficial for patients and reduce hospital acquired infections.

Rejecting the Germ Theory of Disease:

This attitude is reminiscent of the 19th century. In the mid 1800s childbirth was extremely dangerous. Something called childbed fever killed many women shortly after childbirth. In those days doctors did not know about germs.

A physician researcher named Ignaz Semmelweis was practicing medicine at the Vienna General Hospital. He noted that women experienced a much higher death rate after a medical student delivered a baby compared to a midwife.

Dr. Semmelweis discovered that the students were dissecting cadavers in a room next to the maternity wards. They rarely washed their hands after dissections or between deliveries.

The midwives did not deal with the cadavers and thus avoided exposure to such germs. They were far less likely to spread germs from a dead person’s body than were the medical students.

Hand Washing Miracle:

Dr. Semmelweiss suspected that hand washing might make a big difference. He came up with the radical idea that medical students should disinfect their hands after their anatomy labs with the cadavers and between patients. After he instituted this hand hygiene practice the death rate after childbirth dropped dramatically. He didn’t know why the practice worked, he just knew it did.

One might imagine that Dr. Semmelweiss would have become a hero within the medical community and that his discovery would have been quickly adopted. On the contrary. Dr. Semmelweiss became a pariah. His colleagues rejected and ridiculed his research. He was forced into an insane asylum where he soon died. His plea that doctors wash their hands before delivering babies or touching patients was ignored for decades.

The 21st Century Mindset:

Modern medicine likes to pat itself on the back for its patient-centered approach. Yet it seems to us that too many health professionals are willing to accept 100,000 deaths annually as inevitable, just as doctors in the 19th century believed childbed fever was a natural consequence of childbirth.

Dr. Pronovost sums it up beautifully:

“My stance: We could voluntarily ditch the white coats without needing a clinical trial to tell us its OK. We know that white coats can carry pathogens, and it is logical to think that germs could be transmitted from physician to patient. Given that confirming this theory could be prohibitively expensive, we can look at the implications of acting and not acting…

“The real cost of abandoning white coats, it seems has less to do with preventing infections and more to do with the potential emotional or social consequences…”

Read Dr. Pronovost’s brilliant blog here and send it to your doctor or nurse.

Please share your own thoughts about this issue below. Would you think less of your health professional if he or she failed to wear a white coat? What about a tie? Could you bring yourself to ask your doctor to wash his hands or clean his stethoscope? Please vote on this article at the top of the page.

Get The Graedons' Favorite Home Remedies Health Guide for FREE

Join our daily email newsletter with breaking health news, prescription drug information, home remedies AND you'll get a copy of our brand new full-length health guide — for FREE!

  1. ANN MARIE
    home
    Reply

    If the infections and other things would be cut down in hospitals, I vote that the Drs do not wear their WHITE coats into a pts. room. the bed side should all have a bact. hand wash before he/she touches a pt. scope to be cleaned at bedside also. some Drs are very lax at this practice. They are in 2 much of a hurry! I would not be in a hurry to pay the co. pay if they can’t do the right thing for me!

  2. Mariel
    New Mexico, U.S.A.
    Reply

    My husband’s urologist always wore subdued Hawaiian shirts – obviously expensive ones. Our family doctor wears short sleeved pastel lab coats – usually salmon-colored. We haven’t seen white lab coats in years.

  3. EUGENE
    Tampa, Florida
    Reply

    Another hospital pathogen harboring item are the curtains dividing the patient room. I ask the infection control person at a hospital the frequency the curtains are laundered. To my surprise she told me there was NO scheduled laundering, she added, only when a highly infectious patient was in the room would they be changed. With everyone touching the curtain and it being subjected to concentrated germ environment, they should be changed like the bedding is – after every patient at a minimum and optimally daily!

  4. alan
    dallas, tx
    Reply

    wonderful idea. i’ll mention this to him next trip.

  5. JeanB
    Columbia, MO
    Reply

    Re: White Coats/Ties – bare to the elbow.
    I had never heard/read of that before but it makes a lot of sense. I personally don’t care if my Dr. wears a coat/tie or not and what the color is. My one Dr. wears a short sleeved colored shirt/tie and no coat. Fine with me. Anything to cut down on spread of germs!

  6. Liz
    texas
    Reply

    My orthodontist always wore a short-sleeved Mexican wedding shirt or guayabera. With the knife pleats and small scale white embroidery on the white shirt, these made a nice looking uniform. Something like this, with some added symbol could be substituted for the white coat. I’ve noticed that a lot of doctors these days don’t wear a white coat.

  7. Linda C
    Virginia
    Reply

    I recently gave my daughter’s boyfriend a second bow tie. He’ll be starting medical school in the fall. I told him when I gave him the first one that doctors need to switch to bow ties because the long ties are full of germs. Glad to see someone agrees with me. And he got compliments on his bow tie at each of his med school interviews.

What Do You Think?

We invite you to share your thoughts with others, but remember that our comment section is a public forum. Please do not use your full first and last name if you want to keep details of your medical history anonymous. A first name and last initial or a pseudonym is acceptable. Advice from other commenters on this website is not a substitute for medical attention. Do not stop any medicine without checking with the prescriber. Stopping medication suddenly could result in serious harm. We expect comments to be civil in tone and language. By commenting, you agree to abide by our commenting policy and website terms & conditions. Comments that do not follow these policies will not be posted. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your cart

Total
USD
Shipping and discount codes are added at checkout.